Well, now that the leftovers are in the fridge and the china is washed and safely stowed away, I can finally sit down to recap our Thanksgiving. I hosted the big meal for the first time this year and, thankfully, it went pretty smoothly. I always imagined hosting Thanksgiving to be a really stressful and overwhelming endeavor, but I learned a few tricks along the way that actually made it a fairly simple task. In fact, I really enjoyed the process of decorating and cooking this year!
The key for me was to begin preparing several days in advance by breaking the tasks down into manageable pieces. This was my timeline:
- Week Before: create menu, make shopping list, order smoked turkey, call guests to confirm time
- Weekend Before: go grocery shopping, wash china and serving pieces, polish sterling silver flatware, press tablecloth and napkins, set table and buffet and cover everything with a sheet (to keep the clean dishes dust-free until Turkey Day!)
- 2-3 Days Before: prepare pumpkin dip appetizer, cranberry chutney, mashed sweet potatoes, and desserts
- 1 Day Before: prepare stuffing, brew iced tea, arrange fresh flowers for centerpiece
- Thanksgiving Day: watch Macy’s parade, cook turkey, heat up side dishes and rolls, prepare gravy and butternut squash risotto, brew coffee, simmer apple cider in the crockpot
Another thing I found really helpful was to decide in advance which serving pieces and utensils would be used for which foods. Then I wrote the name of the food on an index card and put it inside the corresponding dish to eliminate the guesswork and the frantic, last-minute search for the gravy boat.
Setting the table was my favorite part, of course. Inspired by some leaves, acorns, and seed pods that Jason and I found on a recent hike, I decided to go with a green, brown, and silver color scheme. I turned the leaves into placecards by simply writing each guest’s name on one with a silver paint pen. The acorns added visual interest to clear vases holding candles (other vases were filled with fresh cranberries, dried green peas, and coffee beans). I misted the seed pods with silver spray paint and used them in the centerpiece I created from some store-bought greenery, hydrangeas, feathers, willow branches, and moss. I really liked the contrast between the rustic, natural elements and the more elegant look of our wedding china paired with my great-grandmother’s sterling silver.
Although the table looked lovely and the food was delicious, I would be remiss in not mentioning the great Thanksgiving Day catastrophe of 2010. After lunch, we went to visit my mother-in-law in the hospital and accidentally left some food out on the kitchen counter. When we returned home a while later, we found the turkey carcass in the middle of the floor….and one very happy doggy licking her chops!
Perhaps I should take that as a compliment to the chef?

1 Trackbacks
You can leave a trackback using this URL: http://www.designfinch.com/2010/11/26/thankful/trackback/
[...] plan on following the same preparation timeline as last year, but sprinkling in a few new recipes to keep things interesting. Of course, my favorite part of all [...]
4 Comments
Oh my goodness, my husband and I just had a good laugh over the dog eating the turkey. That is AWESOME!! Your table looked beautiful and I love that you labeled the serving pieces ahead of time. I have totally done that. Good job hosting! I have yet to do that.
Hi Shayla! Just curious–how did you reheat your mashed sweet potatoes for dinner? I’ll be hosting a New Years Eve/delayed Christmas dinner for my family, and the mashed potatoes (regular, not sweet) are one of the things I’d like to make ahead of time. Actually, I was thinking of boiling the potatoes the day before and putting the dish together on the day of. Have you ever heard of anyone doing that?
@Amanda: Hi, Amanda! Reheating the mashed potatoes was easy…I just covered the dish with foil and stuck them in the oven for 30-45 minutes at 350 degrees. You could also reheat them in a crock-pot on low for about 2-3 hours. This is a great option if you are short on oven space.
Peeled potatoes will turn brown-ish if you don’t cook them right away, but I’ve heard that you can peel them in advance, then place them in the fridge overnight covered with water to prevent them from discoloring until you’re ready to cook them.
Good luck hosting your dinner party!
1. Put your peeled potatoes in salted water to keep from turning brown.
2. Consider brining your turkey before you roast it. If you ever do, you’ll never NOT do it! It will make your turkey flavored and more moist than you have ever had. Just google “turkey brine” for great recipes and instructions.